In a highly publicized dispute, the Supreme Court will [have heard] arguments this fall from advocates and opponents to ultimately determine whether federal law, in particular Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, protects transgender employees from discrimination based on their gender identity.1 Along with two other cases concerning the LGBTQ community, the Supreme Court will decide whether the owner of a funeral home violated the law when he fired a former funeral home employee, who informed her employer in 2013 that she struggled with a “gender identity disorder” and announced that she was a transgender woman and that she planned to start working in women’s clothing as opposed to the company’s male dress code of a suit and tie.2
The Supreme Court’s eventual decision will likely impact the employment rights of approximately 1.4 million individuals who identify as transgender in the United States.3 In a recent survey, transgender individuals reported several adverse consequences in their workplace, or in attempts to gain employment, as a result of their gender identity or gender expression, including:
- 27% of the respondents who were employed or applied for a job in the previous year reported being fired, denied a promotion, or not being hired for a job for which they applied;
- 15% of respondents who were employed were verbally harassed, physically attacked, and/or sexually assaulted; and
- More than three-quarters (77%) of respondents took steps to avoid mistreatment in the workplace, including hiding or delaying their transition or reassigning from their employers. 4
Regardless of the Supreme Court’s ruling on whether Title VII protects transgender employees, the trend among many agencies and states is to provide protections for the transgender community. For instance, OSHA expressly states that “[a]ll employees, including transgender employees, should have access to restrooms that correspond to their gender identity.” 5 Citing its sanitation standard, OSHA requires employers “to allow employees prompt access to sanitary facilities”, which includes not placing “unreasonable restrictions on employee use of toilet facilities.”6 This means that employers must do more than provide a unisex bathroom for transgender employees.7
Three years ago, the issue of transgender rights with respect to bathrooms was front and center in North Carolina. Known as the bathroom bill, H.B. 2 required transgender people in government and public buildings to use bathrooms, changing rooms, and showers that corresponded with the gender on their birth certificate.8 A public outcry resulted from the passage of this bill, causing businesses and sporting events to avoid the state and litigation followed. Ultimately, a federal judge in North Carolina approved a settlement in July 2019 that prohibits the state government from banning transgender people from using bathrooms in state buildings that match their gender identity.9 Some states, like California, Oregon, and most recently New York, among others, have passed legislation protecting the rights of transgender individuals to use the bathroom associated with the gender for which they identify.10
In addition to public accommodation, there has been a public push by more than 20 states, as well as the District of Columbia, to institute protections for transgender employees with regard to their employment.11 The EEOC also has taken an aggressive approach to protecting the rights of transgender employees. First, the EEOC adopted its current Strategic Enforcement Plan (SEP) in December of 2012, which includes as a top EEOC enforcement priority “coverage of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender individuals under Title VII’s sex discrimination provisions, as they may apply”.12 In furtherance of this initiative, the Commission’s General Counsel formed an LGBT working group to provide advice and input to Agency litigators on developing litigation-related vehicles.13 Agency litigators have filed lawsuits, as well as amicus curiae briefs, in a number of courts addressing an array of LGBT discrimination-related issues.14
Connecticut, Delaware, Washington D.C., and New York’s employment non-discrimination laws have been amended to provide coverage for sexual orientation and gender identity.
- Adam Liptak, Supreme Court to Decide Whether Landmark Civil Rights Law Applies to Gay and Transgender Workers. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/22/us/politics/supreme-court-gay-transgender-employees.html (April 22, 2019).
- E.E.O.C. v. R.G. & G.R. Harris Funeral Homes, Inc., 884 F.3d 560 (6th Cir. 2018); cert. granted, 139 S.Ct. 1599 (Mem) (2019) (Supreme Court will determine whether Title VII prohibits discrimination against transgender people based on (1) their status as transgender and (2) sex stereotyping).
- Flores, A.R., Herman, J.L., Gates, G.J. & Brown, T.N.T. (2016) How Many Adults Identify as Transgender in the United States? Los Angeles, CA: The Williams Institute.
- James, S.E., Herman, J.L., Rankin, S, Keisling, M., Mottet, L. & Anafi, M. (2016). Executive Summary of the Report of the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey. Washington, D.C.: National Center for Transgender Equality.
- Best Practices. A Guide to Restroom Access for Transgender Workers. (2015) OSHA. https://www.osha.gov › Publications › OSHA3795.
- Id., (citing OSHA 1910.141).
- North Carolina ‘bathroom bill’ settlement approved. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-north-carolina-lgbt/northcarolina-bathroom-bill-settlement-approved-idUSKCN1UI2IJ
- See Cal. Civ. Code § 51(b); Or. Rev. Stat. § 659A.403; and NY Exec App § 466.13.
- Fact Sheet: Recent EEOC Litigation Regarding Title VII & LGBT-Related Discrimination. (last updated 7-8-16) https://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/litigation/selected/lgbt_facts.cfm
This article is part of our Conference Materials Library and has a PowerPoint counterpart that can be accessed in the Resource Libary.
HospitalityLawyer.com® provides numerous resources to all sponsors and attendees of The Hospitality Law Conference: Series 2.0 (Houston and Washington D.C.). If you have attended one of our conferences in the last 12 months you can access our Travel Risk Library, Conference Materials Library, ADA Risk Library, Electronic Journal, Rooms Chronicle and more, by creating an account. Our libraries are filled with white papers and presentations by industry leaders, hotel and restaurant experts, and hotel and restaurant lawyers. Click here to create an account or, if you already have an account, click here to login.